Vrunik Design Solutions

How to Review a UX Design Agency: A Complete Guide

UX Design

8 min read

Blog reading vector doodle
How to Review a UX Design Agency: A Complete Guide
Introduction

Choosing the right UX design agency is crucial for your project’s success, but let’s face it—it’s also pretty overwhelming. There are so many agencies out there, each claiming they can make your website or app look amazing and work even better. But how do you know which one is the best fit for you? You want more than just pretty designs—you want a team that truly understands your users, your business, and how to solve real problems. In this guide, I’ll walk you through everything you need to look for when reviewing a UX design agency, with some real-life examples along the way to make things clearer.

  1. Take a Deep Dive into Their Portfolio
    The first thing you should do when considering a UX agency is take a good, long look at their portfolio. This is where you’ll find the proof of what they can actually do. A strong portfolio tells you a lot about their capabilities, style, and approach.

What to Look For:

    • Variety of Projects: You want to see that the agency has experience across different industries and types of projects. They should be able to handle everything from e-commerce sites to mobile apps to enterprise systems.

      For example, Toptal has worked on everything from fintech (like their project with J.P. Morgan to develop a mobile banking app) to healthcare (they helped Zocdoc streamline appointment scheduling). If they can juggle such a variety, it shows they have range.

       

    • Quality of Design: Sure, aesthetics matter, but don’t stop at the surface. You want to know if the design makes sense for the user. Does the layout work? Is the typography readable? Do the visuals actually help guide the user to what they need?

      Take IDEO, for example. They worked with Ford Motor Company to design a vehicle dashboard that was not only sleek but easy to navigate for drivers. The design wasn’t just pretty; it solved a real user problem—keeping the driver’s attention on the road.

       

    • Problem Solving: You’re not just looking for beautiful designs—you’re looking for agencies that can solve specific problems. Look for case studies that explain how they tackled a challenge and what the results were.

      Frog Design worked with GE Healthcare to redesign a patient monitoring system. By focusing on real-time needs and research, they made the system easier to use, which ultimately saved lives in emergency situations. That’s the kind of problem-solving you want to see.

       

    • Before and After Examples: Nothing shows an agency’s impact like a good before-and-after comparison. If you can see how they improved an existing design, that tells you a lot about their skills.
      Nielsen Norman Group, for instance, often showcases redesigns they’ve done for government websites. In one case, they increased user engagement by 40% just by reorganizing the site’s navigation. Sometimes small changes lead to big results!

Why It Matters:
Looking at an agency’s portfolio is like getting a peek into their brain. You can see their thought process, their design principles, and whether they can deliver on their promises.

 

  1. Understand Their UX Process
    It’s one thing to see what an agency has done, but it’s just as important to understand how they do it. A great design agency should have a clear, user-centered design process. They should focus on your users’ needs and make sure everything aligns with your business goals.

What to Ask About:

    • Research-Driven Approach: Look for agencies that dive deep into user research. This isn’t just about asking a few questions—they should be gathering data, conducting interviews, and doing usability testing to get a real sense of what users want.

      For instance, IDEO worked with The Bill & Melinda Gates Foundation to improve mobile banking for people in rural India. They didn’t just design based on assumptions—they did extensive user research to make sure the app would meet the real needs of users with limited access to technology.

       

    • Wireframing and Prototyping: Before jumping into final designs, the agency should build wireframes and prototypes to test ideas. It’s all about validating concepts early and getting feedback before spending too much time on the wrong direction.
      InVision helped Salesforce with wireframing and prototyping for their mobile app, allowing for quick iterations based on team feedback. This kind of agility is key to making sure the design works in the real world.

       

    • Iterative Process: A good agency doesn’t just create a design and call it a day. They test, get feedback, and refine the design over time. This helps avoid major revisions down the road and ensures the final product is spot-on.

       

    • Dropbox worked with ustwo on their mobile app interface, constantly testing and refining the design. With each iteration, they made the app more intuitive, which helped improve user experience across the board.

       

    • Agile Methodology: Many agencies follow an Agile approach, meaning they’re flexible and can adapt to changing requirements as the project progresses. If you’re working in a fast-paced industry, this is especially important.

       

    • Spotify has been known for using Agile to improve its user experience. By collaborating with users and making small, frequent changes, they keep the product fresh and in line with evolving user expectations.

Why It Matters:
A structured design process is essential for creating a product that truly meets your needs. Without it, you risk getting stuck with designs that miss the mark or don’t solve real user problems.

 

  1. Get to Know the Team
    UX design isn’t just about the final product—it’s about the people behind it. The agency’s team should be diverse and bring a variety of skills to the table. From research to design to testing, it takes more than one person to get it right.

Who to Look For:

 

  • UX Researchers: These folks are the ones who dig deep into understanding your users. They should be experienced in user interviews, surveys, and usability testing.

    For example, Google’s UX Research Team is constantly analyzing user behavior to make their products better. The result? A smooth user experience that meets people’s needs without them even thinking about it.

     

  • UX/UI Designers: These are the creatives who bring everything to life. They should have a keen eye for aesthetics and know how to create intuitive interfaces.

     

  • Figma, the design tool, was built by a team of talented UX/UI designers who understood what designers needed. Their tool changed the game for collaborative design, helping teams work together seamlessly.

     

  • Interaction Designers: These designers focus on how users interact with your product. They make sure the experience is smooth, intuitive, and engaging.

     

  • Airbnb invested heavily in interaction design to create a seamless booking experience. The design was so intuitive that even users unfamiliar with the platform felt comfortable and confident booking accommodations.

     

  • Information Architects: These professionals organize information and ensure users can find what they’re looking for easily.

     

  • LinkedIn redesigned its navigation system, thanks to a stellar IA team. They made it easier for users to discover content and connect with people, which helped boost engagement.

     

  • Usability Experts: These experts ensure that your design is not just user-friendly but also accessible to all users, including those with disabilities.

     

  • The Washington Post revamped their site to be fully accessible, ensuring that everyone, regardless of their abilities, could easily read their content.

Why It Matters:
A team with diverse skills means they can approach every aspect of the project from a different angle. This results in a more well-rounded, thoughtful design that’s more likely to meet your needs.

  1. Communication Is Key
    You could have the best design team in the world, but if they don’t communicate well, the project will fall apart. The agency you choose should be transparent, responsive, and collaborative every step of the way.

What to Expect:

    • Initial Conversations: In your first discussions, do they really listen to your needs? A good agency won’t just talk about their process—they’ll ask you detailed questions to understand your goals.

      For instance, when Slack Technologies worked with InVision, they spent a lot of time early on discussing how teams use communication tools. This helped them design a platform that truly met user needs from day one.

       

    • Transparency: The agency should be open about timelines, costs, and processes. If they’re vague or try to rush you into decisions, that’s a red flag.

       

    • Trello is all about transparency in their design process, which is one of the reasons they’re so successful. They keep their clients in the loop at all times, which helps ensure a smoother workflow.

       

    • Collaboration Tools: Look for agencies that use collaborative tools like Slack, Asana, or Figma to stay in touch with you. These tools make it easy to share ideas, track progress, and stay aligned.

       

    • Dropbox Paper was created using just that kind of collaborative process. It’s a tool designed to help teams work together on documents and ideas in real time.

       

    • Feedback Loops: Make sure there’s room for ongoing feedback. The best designs evolve over time, and the agency should be open to making adjustments based on your input.

       

    • Shopify is a great example of an agency that thrives on continuous feedback. They work closely with clients to iterate on designs quickly and effectively.

Why It Matters:
Good communication keeps the project on track and ensures both you and the agency are aligned. Without it, things can quickly spiral into confusion and frustration.

Conclusion

Finding the right UX design agency is no easy task, but when you follow these steps—checking out their portfolio, understanding their process, evaluating their team, and looking for solid communication—you’ll be in a much better position to make an informed choice. Remember, the goal is to find a team that not only delivers beautiful designs but also solves real problems and aligns with your business goals. When you find the right match, you’ll know it—because the process will feel like a true partnership, not just another project.

Have a question about UX design? Start by viewing our affordable plans, email us at nk@vrunik.com, or call us at +91 9554939637.

Complex Problems, Simple Solutions.

Scroll to Top

Unified User Experiences & Design Systems (Basic Plan)

    Unified User Experiences & Design Systems (Standard Plan)

      Unified User Experiences & Design Systems (Premium Plan)

        Product Modernization & Transformation (Premium Plan)

          Product Modernization & Transformation (Standard Plan)

            Product Modernization & Transformation (Basic Plan)

              Feature Development & Continuous Innovation (Basic Plan)

                Feature Development & Continuous Innovation (Standard Plan)

                  Feature Development & Continuous Innovation (Premium Plan)

                    New Product Conceptualization
                    (Premium Plan)

                      New Product Conceptualization
                      (Standard Plan)

                        New Product Conceptualization (Basic Plan)